|
Transcranial
Doppler Monitoring and the Causes of Stroke from
Carotid Endarterectomy
Merrill P. Spencer, M.D.
Sound Vascular Monitoring and
The Institute of Applied Physiology and Medicine
Seattle, Washington, USA
Acknowledgment: The author thanks Peter Mansfield
M.D., Director of The Heart Center - Providence Seattle Medical Center, for assistance in
statistical analysis.
Abstract
Background and Purpose: The value of carotid
endarterectomy (CEA) depends on the safety of the operation. Transcranial Doppler (TCD)
was used to evaluate the possibilities of hypoperfusion, hyperperfusion, and embolization
as causes of stroke and evaluated the significance of Doppler microembolic signals (DMES).
Methods: Five hundred CEAs were monitored with TCD
on the ipsilateral MCA during various phases of CEA observing for hemodynamic changes and
incidence of DMES. Complications were graded according to their severity and their
probable cause determined from TCD criteria and review of hospital charts.
Results: There were 24(4.8%) CVCs, including 7
with TIAs and 15(3%) with permanent deficits. Among all CVCs embolism was judged to be
responsible in 13(54%) p< 0.02 compared to hypoperfusion, hyperperfusion in 7(29%)
p<0.14 when compared to hypoperfusion, and hypoperfusion in 4(17%) p<0.08 compared
to embolism plus hyperperfusion. The surgeons responded to TCD information by several
strategies depending on the TCD information. The incidence of hospital permanent deficits
diminished from 7.0% in the first 100 operations to 2% for the last 400 p<=0.01.
Shunting was more associated with CVCs than non-shunting, however not significantly so,
p=0.24. Intraoperative DMES numbers were strongly associated with CVCs p=0.02.
Conclusions: Embolism is the principal cause of
CVCs from CEA with hyperperfusion and hypoperfusion also important causes. TCD provides
information to allow prompt identification and treatment of these three major causes of
stroke from this operation. The perioperative stroke rate can be reduced by appropriate
measures, taken by the surgeons, based on findings of TCD monitoring.
Introduction
Surgical excision of atherosclerotic plaque at the
bifurcation of the common carotid artery (CCA) is performed to prevent cerebrovascular
complications (CVCs), however, carotid endarterectomy (CEA) itself can produce CVCs
including disabling stroke and death. Many intraoperative monitoring techniques have been
used to warn the surgeon of the possibility of an adverse outcome 1,2,3,4,5 but
these, including self monitoring under regional block, address only the possibility of
brain hypoperfusion during the time of crossclamping of the carotid arteries. Other major
etiologies recognized included hyperperfusion after release of the clamps 6 and
embolism 7. Recently reports have appeared to expand on the basic causes of
CVCs 8,9,10. In a study of the cause of perioperative stroke after 3062 CEAs 20
different mechanisms were identified but mainly categorized into ischemia from carotid
artery clamping, postoperative thrombosis and embolism, and intracerebral hemorrhage 10.
The hemodynamic and embolic information provided by TCD
monitoring offers the opportunity to identify, in real time, all these major causes
of stroke and give early warning so that preventive measures can be undertaken. The first
reports on TCD in carotid endarterectomy appeared in the late 1980s11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18
and many authors further published for and against its usefulness 19,20,21,22,23 in
measuring hemodynamic and embolic parameters. TCD with simultaneous EEG 24,25,26,27
also proved useful indications of flow in the middle cerebral artery (MCA) and perfusion
of the cortex. Although embolization is generally agreed to be the main cause of cerebral
complications during CEA, it was not until 1990 28,29 that TCD was reported to
detect particulate as well as bubble emboli in this operation. This report relates our
experience with TCD monitoring in determining the hemodynamic and embolic causes and
prevention of CVCs through alterations in surgical techniques and management.
Methods
Included in this report are the first 500 carotid
endarterectomies (CEAs) of the internal carotid artery (ICA) performed between October
1985 and July 1994, in which an ipsilateral temporal bone ultrasonic window could be
found, in which the technologist was able to obtain TCD data throughout the surgery, and
in which complete hospital chart review was obtainable. All charts were completely
reviewed and complications identified by the author. In addition observations were always
made for complications in the recovery room were made by the author, the TCD technologist
and the nursing staff. No patients were included who underwent CEA of the external carotid
artery only and none underwent other concurrent surgical procedures. Indications for CEA
were symptomatic and asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis. Several patients were operated
with stenosis < 60% for reasons including repeating TIAs, the radiologists diagnosis of
ulceration, radiologist overestimation of stenosis compared to micrometer diameter
measurements of the angiograms e.g. area percentage vs. diameter percentage, and occlusion
of the contralateral artery. Forty four patients underwent a previous CEA of the
contralateral ICA. Eight underwent repeat CEA on the same ICA and one patient underwent
contralateral CEA as well as a repeat CEA.
The preoperative symptoms of the patients were classified
as:
Asymptomatic - patient denies all symptoms of
cerebrovascular insufficiency over the past 6 months or complains of non-lateralizing
cerebral symptoms such as dizziness, headaches, et cetera.
TAF - transient unilateral monocular blindness.
TIA or RIND - transient lateralizing symptoms of
cerebrovascular insufficiency and speech deficits but not including unilateral monocular
blindness.
Stroke - recent persistent unilateral symptoms of
cerebrovascular insufficiency.
Twenty one operations were performed under sedation and
regional anesthesia. The remainder were conducted under general anesthesia using nitrous
oxide in oxygen and Isoflurane or Enflurane after induction with thiopental. The
operations were performed by 23 vascular surgeons in seven community hospitals of three
western counties of Washington State. Shunting of the endarterectomy site was performed in
297 (59%) of operations including nine incomplete attempts. One hundred twenty-seven (25%)
operations were performed without angiography with the severity of stenosis based on the
highest frequencies found with 5 MHz CW Doppler. The following scale was verified in 222
of the cases where both angiograms and Doppler examinations were carried out. <3Khz,0%
stenosis; 3,10%; 4,20%; 5-6,30%; 7-8,40%; 9-10,50%; 11-13,60%; 14-15,70%; 16-18, 80%;
>18,90%.
The middle cerebral artery (MCA) flow velocity signals
were monitored with a 2 MHz pulse Doppler probe * placed over the temporal bone, on the
operated side, and focused on the MCA at a depth of 45 or 50 mm with a focal length of 20
mm. A special headband was used to hold a ball-shaped transducer with a position locking
mechanism allowing hands-off monitoring. Positive identification of the MCA was confirmed
by responses on the Doppler spectrum to finger oscillations of the cervical CCA or
intraoperative surgical manipulations of the carotid arteries.
* Transpect©, manufactured by Medasonics Inc.
TCD monitoring phases were defined as: Preoperative
Before anesthesia, Dissection During surgical exposure of the carotid arteries up
to the time of crossclamping of the common carotid artery, Crossclamping including
shunting, if performed, Release 5 minutes following removal of the carotid artery
clamps, Closure the period following release up to final closure of the skin
incision, Recovery the following period until recovery from anesthesia, and Follow-up
After recovery from the anesthetic including the following hospitalization day after
surgery.
At the time of crossclamping of the CCA the decrease in
mean MCA velocity was calculated as the percentage of the remaining velocity compared to
the pre-crossclamp velocity 23 after 10 seconds were allowed for autoregulation
adjustment. Upon release of the crossclamp, following closing of the arteriotomy, the
percentage increase in velocity was calculated as the velocity after 15 minutes compared
to the pre-crossclamp velocity. The Doppler signals, voice annotations and spectral
signals were recorded on audio-video tape for detailed analysis.
DMES in the MCA were recognized by combined audio and
spectral criteria previously published 29,30 and their numbers and the
observation time were recorded for each phase of surgery. DMES occurring within the
release phase were considered to primarily represent bubbles of air but particulate matter
may have been present. If they occurred before opening of the artery or after the release
phase they were considered to represent particulates, or formed element emboli. The
surgeons were informed of relevant information during the surgery and their responses
recorded. The tape recordings were analyzed postoperatively for velocity changes and DMES.
The abstracted TCD measurements were entered into an analytical database. Statistical
analysis used chi squared, two tailed T Students test and statistical significance was
considered when p<0.05.
During the first 100 operations TCD criteria were
developed to identify the risks of intraoperative hypoperfusion, hyperperfusion, and
embolism as well as strategies for cerebral protection. Surgeons were continuously
informed of TCD information throughout all operations. Causal criteria analyzed to
determine the etiology of CVCs were:
HYPOPERFUSION - Intraoperative MCA velocities less than
30% of the pre-carotid crossclamp value for more than 5 minutes. Forty percent of the
pre-crossclamp value can be tolerated indefinitely 23 intraoperatively, as well
as postoperatively, if carotid artery occlusion occurs;
HYPERPERFUSION - persistence of MCA velocities >1.5
times the pre-crossclamp values, during shunting or following final release of the carotid
crossclamps, without adequate corrective measures;
EMBOLISM - failure to meet the previous two hemodynamic
criteria and the persistence of DMES during the intraoperative and recovery phases, except
for the release phase, or postoperatively without adequate preventive measures. No special
limitations on the microembolic numbers or rates were established but the surgeons became
sensitive to their occurrence and measures were frequently taken to minimize their
numbers.
CVCs were identified during the post surgical
hospitalization beginning in the recovery room and by examination of the following patient
records: all hospital chart notes of the anesthesiologist, surgeon, and nurses and
progress notes, consultation notes, and discharge summaries. CVCs were graded according to
severity of clinically evident injury as follows:
Grade I: TIA or RIND
Grade II: Residual Deficits Not
Impairing Ordinary Daily Activities
Grade III: Impairment Necessitating
Assistance With Some Ordinary Activities
Grade IV: Requiring Assistance With
All Ordinary Activities
Grade V: Coma Or Death
CVCs were considered to occur intraoperatively if symptoms
were noted upon recovery from the anesthetic. They were considered to occur
postoperatively if symptoms developed after recovery from the anesthetic. The probable
cause of each CVC was determined 1) from the TCD criteria, 2) reopening the arteriotomy
and inspection for thrombus or occlusion, 3) postoperative ultrasound examination to
confirm ICA and MCA patency, and 4) when available CCT findings and the opinions in a
neurologist's consultation.
Results
Among the 500 CEAs there were no deaths but 24 CVCs
occurred for a 4.8% rate with a 95% confidence interval from 2.9% to 6.7%. There were 15
permanent deficits, beyond the 9 TIAs, for a stroke rate of 3% with a 95% confidence
interval from 1.5% to 4.5%. Fourteen complications occurred intraoperatively and 10
postoperatively. Table 1 lists all of the CVCs with the principal hemodynamic, embolic,
and other data used to determine the probable cause of the complications. Among all CVCs
embolism was judged to be responsible in 13(54%) p<0.02 compared to hypoperfusion,
hyperperfusion in 7(29%) p<0.14 when compared to hypoperfusion, and hypoperfusion in
4(17%) p<0.08 compared to embolism plus hyperperfusion. More than one causal factor
sometimes appeared to be involved, but the primary cause was usually identifiable.
During the crossclamp phase MCA velocities decreased below
30% of their pre-crossclamp values in 81 (16%) of operations. The surgeons responded to
hypoperfusion threat by shunting or attempted shunting except in 3 cases when no shunt was
used and no CVC resulted. The time without shunting, in these 3 cases, was 17, 21, and 21
minutes with the residual crossclamp MCA velocities 7, 18, and 28% respectively. The
arterial pressure was increased in these cases to improve perfusion. Presumably cortical
collateral played a part to provide adequate perfusion in all three. Other responses to
hypoperfusion included adjustment of an occluded shunt, intermittent release of the clamps
when extra time was needed for suturing of the arteriotomy, and reopening and
re-inspecting the operative site for intimal flaps or an occluding thrombus. Surgeons
whose policy was to routinely shunt began to rely on TCD information for selective
shunting. Those surgeons who used a shunt selectively, based on stump pressure
measurements, eventually abandoned the pressure technique and relied solely on the TCD
velocity information to decide for or against use of a shunt.
Following release of the crossclamps MCA velocities
abruptly increased above pre-clamp values and then usually decreased toward the pre-clamp
values. In 73 (15%) of operations they persisted at values above twice the pre-clamp
values. In 3 (4.1%) of these there were subsequent complications. In two of the three,
hyperperfusion was considered the primary cause and in the third one it was considered a
secondary cause. Measures to prevent hyperperfusion included intraoperative temporary
partial occlusion of the CCA, lowering of the arterial pressure, induction of hypocarbia
by increased pulmonary ventilation, and infusion of Nitroprusside or other hypotensive
agent. Figure 1 illustrates the sequence of events in a patient with hyperperfusion and
treatment by control of the arterial blood pressure. This patient was a 71 year male
normotensive who preoperatively had a left hemispheric TIA. Angiograms were interpreted to
represent 80-90% narrowing of the LICA but micrometer measurements of the ICA represented
50% diameter stenosis. Doppler and Duplex examinations diagnosed a 30% stenosis. When the
surgeons were notified of hyperperfusion danger they lowered the arterial pressure and
partially pinched off the CCA to decrease the MCA velocities. No postoperative headache or
CVC occurred in this patient.
The prevalence and numbers of DMES during the
perioperative phases are shown in Table 2. For this analysis all intraoperative phases
including dissection, crossclamping, release, and closure were grouped together. The
preoperative prevalence of one or more DMES in the MCA in all 500 cases was 16%. However,
analyzing those monitored for more than 5 minutes, to eliminate trivial monitoring times,
the preoperative prevalence in 443 cases increased to 19%. In this group the difference
between the preoperative number of DMES / minute in CVC cases and non-CVC cases was not
significant p=0.95. During the intraoperative phases the DMES prevalence was 93% and the
difference in DMES between the CVC and non-CVC cases was significant, p=0.02. The
difference during the recovery phase, between CVC and non-CVCs, was marginally
significant, p=0.06. These statistics were computed from the 2 tailed T test.
When the surgeons released the ECA and CCA clamps, before
release of the ICA, DMES were frequently detected in the MCA presumably passing retrograde
through the ophthalmic artery which served as a collateral channel to the ICA. Though
these were mainly considered bubbles and were not treated with the same seriousness as
particulate DMES of other phases, the surgeons responded to release DMES by altering their
techniques to more thoroughly eliminate intralumenal air before final closure of the
arteriotomy. No decrease in MCA velocity was observed following any of the DMES. This
observation suggests that they, individually or in clusters upon clamp release, did not
greatly obstruct MCA flow. Surgeons responded to the presence of particulate DMES during
surgical maneuvers with more care during the dissection, early crossclamping of the distal
ICA prior to dissection of the CCA and ECA, and administration of extra heparin.
Postoperative DMES were responded to by administration of heparin, intravenous Dextran,
and by increased alertness to possible postoperative complications.
Table 3 indicates a tendency for embolism to be more
associated with lesser grades of CVCs and for hemodynamic factors to be associated with
more severe grades of CVCs. For the distribution of CVCs found among the 3 causes of Table
3 p<0.07. Considering only hypoperfusion and hyperperfusion incidence p<0.14.
Considering only embolic and hypoperfusion cause the p<0.08 and p=0.17 by Bonferroni
adjustment. Comparing only the emboli and hypoperfusion data, p<0.02 and therefore the
distribution between these 2 causes is statistically significant.
Table 4 shows that shunting was more associated with CVCs
than non-shunting, although the difference was not statistically different, p= 0.24. CVCs
from embolization appeared equally distributed among the shunted and non-shunted cases.
Hyperperfusion accounted for the major difference between shunted and non-shunted
operations with seven CVCs in the shunted operations while none of the non-shunted
operations sustained a hyperperfusion outcome. This finding suggests non-shunted cases
were adequately perfused before surgery and also during crossclamping with their
collateral and autoregulation mechanisms adequate or unchallenged. In nine of the shunted
operations placement was only partially successful with the non-shunted duration of
crossclamping ranging from 10 to 58 minutes. Among these nine partially shunted case there
were 4 CVCs (44%). Embolism was considered the primary cause in three and a secondary
factor in one. Table 1 indicates the secondary causes of CVCs when appropriate.
Post-surgical occlusion of the operated ICA was found in
six of the CVC patients, three occurring intraoperatively and three postoperatively. All
ICA occlusions were confirmed by reopening the arteriotomy with finding of thrombosis of
the ICA. Three out of the five patients with ICA occlusion demonstrated microemboli in the
recovery room prior to return to the operating room. Embolization from the occluding
thrombus was concluded to be the cause of complications in five of the six occlusions
because crossclamp velocities and stump pressures were considered adequate to maintain
global perfusion even without anesthesia protection. In the sixth case, hypoperfusion was
concluded to be the cause but large numbers of microemboli, detected in the recovery room,
was thought to be a contributing factor.
There was one ipsilateral MCA occlusion (patient # 347,
Table 1) thought to be due to primary thrombosis developing at the site of a 50% MCA
stenosis detected by TCD and seen on the preoperative angiogram. This patient was
initially referred to surgery for a RIND and a 90% stenosis of the ICA. Thrombosis of the
MCA was completed in 6 hours postoperatively when the patient became comatose and Doppler
examination of the cervical ICA and the MCA confirmed MCA occlusion. In this patient there
were only seven microembolic signals occurring during a 100-minute dissection phase and no
microemboli seen in a 60-minute recovery phase suggesting the occlusion was the result of
primary thrombosis of the MCA and not embolization from the operative site. Three
postoperative CCT examinations demonstrated old infarctions in the left posterior
parietal-occipital area and no hemorrhage.
Table 5 discloses the CVCs by preoperative symptom
category. There was no significant difference between the number of strokes in 239
asymptomatic patients and 261 symptomatic patients, p=0.30. It appears the most risk free
symptomatic category included those patients referred for amaurosis fugax, and patients
referred for hemispheric symptoms sustained the highest rate of CVCs, however, in 2 x3
cross tabulation analysis of the 3 symptomatic categories p= 0.20. Among the 44 patients
with a prior contralateral CEA there were no complications. Among the 8 undergoing a
repeat ipsilateral CEA there was 1 with a grade 1 complication from the first operation
and one grade 3 complication with the second CEA. One of the 8 sustained a grade 3 stroke
due to a thrombus developing at the site of the crossclamp of the CCA. There were no
hospital complications among the 21 regional anesthesia patients, though only six were
referred for hemispheric symptoms and the numbers of patients are insufficient for
separate statistical analysis.
There were 499 cases with the percent stenosis quantitated
by either angiography or Doppler using the method giving the greatest severity. Of the
499, 190 (38%) had stenosis <70% and 309 (62%) had stenosis >= 70%). Twelve CVCs
occurred in the 190 cases with <70% stenosis for a 6.3% complication rate and 12 CVCs
occurred in the 309 cases >=70% stenotic for a 3.9% rate p= 0.22. There was no
statistically significant difference between symptomatic cases with >=70% and the cases
with <70% stenosis where in 156 cases with >=70% there were 8 CVCs (5.1%) while in
105 with <70% there were 7 CVCs (6.7%) with p=0.61. Likewise there was no difference
between asymptomatic cases with >= 60% stenosis and cases with <60% stenosis where
in 200 cases with >= 60% stenosis there were 8 CVCs (4.0%) while in 38 cases with
<60% stenosis there was 1 CVC (2.6%) with p=0.68.
The proportion of patients in asymptomatic vs. symtomatic
categories was the same among the 1st 100 and the last 400 cases i.e. 48% were
asymptomatic in both groups of cases. The incidence of permanent deficits diminished from
7% in the first 100 operations to 2% for the last 400, p<=0.012. For all CVCs the
incidence diminished from 8% in the first 100 to 4% in the last 400, p<= 0.11.
Discussion
In this study it appears that embolization represents the
main cause of hospital cerebral complications from CEA with hyperperfusion as the second
major cause. Hypoperfusion is the least frequent cause of CVCs in this study where 59% of
cases were shunted. Even so, this later finding, along with the higher complication rate
for shunted operations, suggests that shunting may be advisable only in highly selected
cases and should be particularly avoided when difficulties in placement are anticipated.
This conclusion was also reached by a previous large group study 31.
Cortical collateral, may, account for tolerance to
crossclamping with MCA velocities below the 30% level for extended periods in some
patients. The residual MCA velocity after crossclamp may be reduced by cortical collateral
whose effect would be in an opposite direction to the collateral from the circle of
Willis. The presence of cortical collateral, however, does not invalidate the shunting
criteria use here because any error from this effect is on the side of safety.
In this study no single embolus or combination of
microemboli has been recognized which clearly produced the embolic complications but
transient decreases in MCA velocity have been reported associated the embolic showers 32
in the recovery room which have led to CVCs. It was not possible in the present study to
completely monitor the entire intraoperative and postoperative time periods and therefore
a large embolus or group of particulate emboli may well have been missed, however, DMES
are clearly more associated with CVC cases than in those without CVC. Controlling the
numbers of microemboli appears to prevent the development of large, clinically significant
emboli and saves brain tissue from many small infarcts as reported by others 31.
The size of microemboli cannot, as yet, be measured but multifrequency techniques show
great promise 34,35.
The evidence here that TCD monitoring has reduced the
incidence of cerebral injury is based on improvement of outcomes since our initial
experience and also on the actions by the surgeons based on the TCD information. A
randomized blinded study will be difficult to perform in this environment because of the
convictions of many vascular surgeons that the technique represents good medical practice
and what is learned from the monitored cases will be applied to those not monitored thus
rendering comparison difficult between monitored and non-monitored patient groups. The
work of others using TCD in CEA confirms the present results 36,37.
Problems with TCD Monitoring of CEA patients mainly relate
to finding and holding the MCA signal throughout the surgery because of the narrow, and
sometimes non-existent, temporal bone window. Fifteen percent of CEA patients (13% of
women and 5% of men) do not have an adequate transtemporal window to allow insonation of
the MCA. Improved headbands and application techniques are now available to stabilize the
probe and allow hands-off bilateral monitoring in most cases.
Conclusions
Nineteen percent of carotid endarterectomy patients
demonstrate microemboli to the MCA.
Embolism from the operative site during carotid
endarterectomy is the principal cause of CVCs exceeding hypoperfusion (p<0.02) with
hyperperfusion and hypoperfusion also significant causes.
Post-arteriotomy occlusion of the ICA by thrombosis is a
major cause of CVCs with the major mechanism being embolization from the thrombosed
artery.
TCD monitoring provides relevant on-line information to
allow prompt identification and treatment of three major causes of CVCs from CEA.
TCD information provided to the vascular surgeon
perioperative to carotid endarterectomy leads to alterations in surgical techniques and
patient management.
The perioperative stroke rate can be reduced by
appropriate measures by the surgeons, based on findings of TCD monitoring, p<=0.01..
Doppler microembolic signals are produced intraoperatively
in more than 90% of all carotid endarterectomies with or without cerebral complications.
The numbers, however, of intraoperative Doppler microemboli signals are strongly
associated with CVCs from CEA p=0.02.
TCD monitoring of CEAs provides important knowledge about
the mechanisms of cerebral complications in carotid endarterectomy.
There is no statistically significant difference between
the number of carotid endarterectomy strokes in asymptomatic and symptomatic patients,
p=0.30.
Shunting of the operative site may be associated with more
complications than non-shunting, particularly when difficulties are encountered with
inserting the shunt.
Shunting is recommended in a small percentage of patients
who can be selected on the basis of TCD detected velocity changes after crossclamping of
the common carotid artery.
References
|
No. |
Sx |
%Stn |
pSt |
% vX |
Shu |
tXC |
vR% |
IOE |
RCE |
Gr
|
CAUSE |
|
184 |
D |
40 |
62 |
90 |
N |
31 |
1.3 |
2 |
14 |
1
|
IO Emb +Hyper due to
Hyperten |
|
151 |
D |
70 |
8 |
3 |
Y/N |
15 |
1.4 |
263 |
97 |
1
|
IO Emb +Hypo when ICA
occ. * |
|
313 |
T |
53 |
- |
82 |
N |
28 |
1.8 |
45 |
1 |
2
|
IO Emb, CTT shows
non-hem infarct |
|
77 |
A |
87 |
50 |
74 |
N |
26 |
1.3 |
21 |
5 |
3
|
IO Emb from non-occ.
thrombus * |
|
50 |
T |
27 |
54 |
83 |
N |
28 |
1.2 |
32 |
0 |
2
|
IO Emb, ICA patent
CTT negative |
|
529 |
T |
80 |
- |
41 |
Y |
5 |
1.3 |
203 |
7 |
3
|
IO Emb in dissection
phase |
|
174 |
T |
84 |
50 |
94 |
Y/N |
58 |
1.3 |
6 |
44 |
1
|
IO Emb in recovery room |
|
496 |
T |
50 |
- |
79 |
Y |
4 |
2.6 |
45 |
16 |
2
|
IO Emb when ICA occ.
from clot * |
|
192 |
A |
80 |
- |
71 |
N |
31 |
0.9 |
102 |
0 |
1
|
IO Emb when ICA occ.
from clot * |
|
21 |
S |
90 |
- |
57 |
Y |
4 |
1.7 |
13 |
- |
2
|
IO Hyper & cerebral
hem |
|
204 |
S |
75 |
- |
53 |
Y |
5 |
1.9 |
47 |
0 |
1
|
IO Hyper around recent
infarct |
|
401 |
A |
67 |
- |
14 |
Y |
6 |
1.1 |
2 |
0 |
1
|
IO Hypo +Emb from shunt |
|
233 |
A |
60 |
23 |
33 |
Y/N |
11 |
1.0 |
46 |
0 |
4
|
IO Hypo +Emb in surgery
from shunt |
|
347 |
R |
91 |
- |
1 |
Y |
6 |
1.2 |
15 |
0 |
4
|
IO Hypo when MCA occ.
|
|
468 |
A |
60 |
- |
37 |
Y |
3 |
1.2 |
75 |
25 |
2
|
PO Emb continuing 36/hr
next day |
|
281 |
D |
60 |
- |
77 |
N |
32 |
1.2 |
0 |
32 |
2
|
PO Emb from ICA occ.
clot * |
|
13 |
T |
60 |
- |
55 |
Y/N |
10 |
0.0 |
0 |
0 |
3
|
PO Emb from ICA occ.
thrombus * |
|
492 |
T |
56 |
- |
7 |
Y |
3 |
1.3 |
42 |
4 |
3
|
PO Emb. ICA patent by
Doppler |
|
33 |
T |
90 |
19 |
38 |
Y |
4 |
2.7 |
43 |
7 |
5
|
PO Hyper +Emb in ICU,
CTT hem |
|
328 |
TAF |
80 |
- |
37 |
Y |
8 |
1.0 |
9 |
0 |
1
|
PO Hyper, CTT hem.
lesion |
|
445 |
TAF |
51 |
- |
58 |
Y |
3 |
1.5 |
8 |
0 |
1
|
PO Hyper, ICA open by
duplex |
|
70 |
A |
80 |
20 |
46 |
Y |
6 |
0.9 |
261 |
0 |
3
|
PO Hyper, Hypten.
ICA&MCA patent |
|
99 |
T |
99 |
- |
73 |
Y |
4 |
2.1 |
- |
- |
1
|
PO Hyper, no emboli
detected § |
|
89 |
TAF |
60 |
37 |
34 |
N |
52 |
0.8 |
50 |
0 |
5
|
PO Hypo from ICA occ.
|
Legend: Table
1. Probable Causes and Relevant Information in 24 Cerebrovascular Complications From
Carotid Endarterectomy. The primary cause for each complication is listed immediately
following IO or PO in the last column. No.= patient number; Sx= Preoperative Symptom code
where A= asymptomatic, D= dizzyness, T= hemispheric TIA, TAF= amaurosis fugax, R= RIND,
and S= stroke; % Stn= percent stenosis; pSt= stump pressure; % vX= percent mean MCA
velocity of pre-crossclamp value; Shu= Shunt Yes No; YN= attempted but withdrawn for more
than 10 minutes during crossclamping; tXC= longest time in minutes the carotids were
crossclamped without a shunt in place; vR%= MCA velocity after release / pre-crossclamp
velocity; IOE= total number of intraoperative microemboli; RCE= number of microemboli
detected in the recovery room; Gr= grade of CVC severity; Cause= probable cause of the
CVC; IO= intraoperative; PO= postoperative; Emb= Embolism, Hyper= Hyperperfusion, Hypo=
Hypoperfusion; += secondary cause, occ.= occlusion; hypten.= hypertension, hem.=
hemorrhage, * = verified by surgical reopening of the artery; = verified by
postoperative CTT; = verified by post-operative Duplex or Doppler. A blank= no
information recorded; § = no tape available for review but technologist reported no
microemboli detected.
Table 2. Microembolic Signals and
Perioperative Phases
-CVC yes- - CVC no -
PHASE
Prv5min DMES (min) n DMES/min n
p
PREOPERATIVE
19%
0.043 (20) 0.029
423
0.95
INTRAOPERATIVE 93%
0.68 (22)
0.37
439
0.02
RECOVERY
36%
0.67 (22)
0.30
389
0.06
Legend Table 2. Prevalence and average numbers of DMES in
perioperative phases of CEA. Prv5min= prevalence among cases monitored for more than 5
minutes, DMES / min= average number of DMES divided by the total minutes monitored, n=
number of cases in each sample.
Table 3. Cerebral Complication
Grade and Causes
|
GRADE |
EMBO |
HYPER |
HYPO |
TOTALS |
PERCENT |
|
I |
4 |
4 |
1 |
9 |
38% |
|
II |
5 |
1 |
0 |
6 |
25% |
|
III |
4 |
1 |
0 |
5 |
21% |
|
IV |
0 |
0 |
2* |
2 |
8% |
|
V |
0 |
1 |
1 |
2 |
8% |
|
TOTALS |
13 |
7 |
4 |
24 |
|
|
PERCENT |
54% |
29% |
17% |
100% |
100% |
Legend Table 3.
Severity and Distribution of 24 Cerebrovascular Complications
According to Probable Cause EMBO= embolization, HYPO=
hypoperfusion, HYPER= hyperperfusion, *= one patient had occlusion of the MCA.
Table 4. Shunting and Causes of
Cerebral Complications
| |
N |
EMBO |
HYPO |
HYPER |
TOTAL CVCs |
| SHUNTED |
297 |
7 |
3 |
7 |
175.7% |
| NOT
SHUNTED |
203 |
6 |
1 |
0 |
73.4% |
|
TOTALS |
500 |
13 |
4 |
7 |
24 4.8% |
Legend Table 4.
Cerebrovascular Complications in Shunted and Non-shunted Carotid Endarterectomies
Table 5. Cerebral Complications and Preoperative
Symptoms
Preoperative
Symptoms
|
Complications
|
| |
n
Patients
|
All
CVCs
|
Strokes
|
|
ASYMPTOMATIC |
239
|
9
|
3.8%
|
5
|
|
SYMPTOMATIC |
261
|
15
|
5.7%
|
10
|
|
Amaurosis Fugax |
78
|
3
|
3.8%
|
1
|
|
Stroke |
45
|
2
|
4.4%
|
1
|
|
TIA and RIND |
135
|
10
|
7.2%
|
8
|
|
TOTAL ALL CASES |
500
|
24
|
4.8%
|
15
|
Legend Table 5.
Cerebrovascular Complications (CVCs) from Carotid Endarterctomy According to Preoperative
Symptoms.
|